Follow us on

Listen to Long Island's #1 Rock Station Online!

recent on-air advertisers

Now Playing

102.3 WBAB
Listen to Long ...

Posted: 9:53 a.m. Wednesday, Aug. 22, 2012

Where’s the Best Ice Cream on Long Island? 

Ice Cream
Ice Cream

By Donna Donna

Summer goes by way too fast!

It’s time to get in our last licks and maybe time to go beyond the neighborhood and explore some of the ice-cream shops Long Islanders rave about on Yelp. 
 
The Hollow Creamery, Carle Place: Bill S says “These are really good people making really great home made ice cream in small batches with the best ingredients. I tried to tell them that they should charge more money for this amazing ice cream but they didn't listen.”


Coyle's, Bayshore: Quite a few Yelpers discovered Coyle’s on their way home from Robert Moses. Justin F recommends the Bailey's and Cake Batter flavors and says, "Everyone I bring here has come to the conclusion that this place serves the best ice cream and I totally agree." 
 
Krisch's, Massapequa: Christopher S recommends the "Massapequa Special – two scoops of ice cream, marshmallow sauce, hot fudge, and homemade whip cream scooped right from the mixing bowl."

In the Mood, Woodbury: Tracy K says, "flavors like pear and peach wine are constantly made on premises. This ordinary looking little store is doing what no other places are doing." 
 
Five Pennies Creamery, Rockville Center: Wolf G says the Curious George flavor here is "sweet, with undertones of bananas, cinnamon, and caramel." 
 
Magic Fountain, Mattituck: Jeff G says “The s'mores and hazelnut biscotti flavors…were absolutely unreal. These flavors are well fleshed-out and not somebody's off-and-on experimentation.”
 
Snowflake, Riverhead: Nicole C says the ice cream here is "ultra rich, smooth, and creamy – it's easy to see why this place is always buzzing with locals and visitors alike."
 
Marvel, Long Beach: Chris T calls Marvel a "magical place" and recommends the "strawberry ice cream in a waffle cone covered in toasted coconut." 
 
Marshall's, Massapequa: Jennifer V says Marshall’s “has the formula for success down: generous servings + friendly staff + great selection = paradise for ice cream lovers."

 

Donna  Donna

About Donna Donna

Hi, I'm Donna Donna. I was just a kid when the British invasion blew my mind! I was a flower lovin' hippie.

Connect with Donna Donna on:TwitterFacebook

Send Donna Donna an email.

 
 
 

© 2013 Cox Media Group. By using this website, you accept the terms of our Visitor Agreement and Privacy Policy, and understand your options regarding Ad ChoicesAdChoices.

Rovi Portions of Content Provided by Rovi Corporation. © 2012 Rovi Corporation